Vet 'n' wild

TV Emma blasts 'animal cruelty'

FURY: Emma
FURY: Emma
UPSET: Chris
UPSET: Chris

TELLY animal experts last night blasted I'm A Celeb for being cruel . . . to INSECTS.

BBC's One Show vet Emma Milne branded the bushtucker trials "repulsive"-and says she refuses to watch the ITV1 series.

And Autumnwatch host Chris Packham says he's "appalled" by tasks which include eating live insects and being covered by them.

He told the News of the World: "What sickens me more than anything is when people say 'They're only insects.' I happen to like insects and, more than anything, I like life.

"There's not a single living organism on this planet that wants to die."

Last week Joe Swash and Nicola McLean MUNCHED live crickets, silkworms and a witchety grub in one trial. Two days later Robert Kilroy-Silk DOWNED an insect smoothie, SHOVED his head in a box of rats, was PLASTERED in gloop and insects, and had to PUSH snakes aside to win food.

Emma, star of Vet's School and Vets In Practice, fumed: "The creatures are put in a completely unnatural situation.

"And the thing where the celebs bite the head off a live whatever-well, it's pathetic if that's what we need to do to entertain people."

And Chris Packham said: "I've been appalled by the way the animals are abused.

"When I saw what appeared to be mealworms, maggots, gunk and a sackload of cockroaches being poured over Kilroy, there was no doubt huge numbers of creatures would be trampled on and stuck in the mess. If they trod on a cat, it'd be on every front page. But they can jump up and down on as many bugs as they like and I find that appalling.

Chris disputed claims that insects don't feel pain. He said: "Sorry but that's bloody sub-GCSE anatomy. They've got nervous systems. Witchety grubs and mealworms shy away from heat. Of course these creatures have feelings."

He also alleged bigger animals had been harmed on I'm A Celeb.

"Several years ago a star had to put their head inside a Perspex tank of giant spiders.

"I could see they'd done something to the spiders' fangs to make them harmless," Chris said.

"Another time I saw crocodiles with their mouths tied together. It's despicable."

Animal charity Peta also slammed the stunts, saying: "They send a very dangerous message that cruelty towards other living beings is acceptable."

An I'm A Celebrity spokesman said: "Australia's RSPCA is notified of all trials involving mammals or reptiles and inspectors have an open invitation to attend any trial.

"We also have qualified, experienced animal and insect wranglers on site at every trial, and each one is carefully tested and developed.

"And many of the insects used are bred for feeding reptiles."

DO you think that I'm A Celebrity is cruel? Post your comments below.

Your comments

This article has 8 comments

People are worried about people killing kids, do you not reed the newspapers and listen to the news Melanie! This is on a different subject of animal cruelty and anyone who thinks this is all ok it nuts, animals have feelings just like us, even insects, what makes us think we have the right??? thank goodness we have people like the RSPCA, vets, Cat Protection League etc because the majority in the general population do not seem to give a s""it and it is APPARENTLY more important to be entertained, typical of the human race really! at least there are some decent peole who speak up for animal rights and donate to animal charities!

By Karen. Posted December 7 2008 at 10:46 AM.

If Chris Packham and Emma think that anyone really cares about annoying insects they really do need to live in the real world.

Who do you know in this world ( who is on this planet ) would think twice of killing a cochroach if it was in your house or on you??

Im sure the two of them have both killed an insect in thier time with not entertaining anyone. ITV killed a few but entertained 9 million views.

I have respect for vets.. but these two just like to see thier name in the paper ... Get a life ( or get in the jungle next year chris,I bet you would **** yourself!!

By Neville William. Posted December 6 2008 at 11:57 PM.

its catch 22, all the reptiles an rodents are treated carfully, but all the spiders an bugs as people have rightly said are jus trod on, stuck on people an everything. something needs to be done to protect the bugs i know people dont like them but they cant get away.

By Rachael. Posted December 4 2008 at 10:13 PM.

I've thought this for a while... in pretty much every trial you see creatures getting stamped on or dropped from great heights or eaten alive. Not very pleasant to watch. And Johan, what on earth does any of that mean? It's nonsense.

By Sarah. Posted November 30 2008 at 9:39 AM.

This sort of programme show the public that animals are to be used and abused for OUR entertainment.


By Paul Timpson. Posted November 24 2008 at 1:45 PM.

Its about time someone has stood up and made a point on how the animals and insects are treated. I have stopped watching the programme because of this.

By Patricia Green. Posted November 23 2008 at 4:19 PM.

I've got to agree....As much as I enjoy the programme, the disregard for animal welfare sits uneasily with me....
Oh, and Johan, could you rethink and rephrase what you were trying to say in the previous comment - it makes little or no sense.........

By Melanie. Posted November 23 2008 at 1:59 PM.

killing kids that's what u should be worried about and people soon you lot will say don't kill flies
get your acts togetter

By Johan. Posted November 23 2008 at 7:19 AM.

Post your comment here

We have to check every comment before we can allow it to be published. But don't worry, we've got a team on it 24/7 - so check back soon! Please note that we cannot publish all comments received. The editor's decision is final. Please note that your email address will not be displayed next to your comment.

We are No1 for Videos